SNP government in ‘dangerous denial’ over benefits spending bill
The Scottish Government says it does not accept there is a need to make ‘arbitrary cuts’ to benefits spending in Scotland.
The SNP is in “dangerous denial” about the rising cost of Scotland’s benefits bill, after its education chief said she does not accept the need to make “arbitrary cuts”.
On Tuesday the Milburn Review recommended cutting some benefits for young adults in a bid to get more of them into employment, education or training.
If this happens, it could have a knock-on impact on the Scottish Government’s ability to fund the likes of the adult disability payment in Scotland.


More than half of the Scottish welfare budget is spent on the adult disability payment, and last year Audit Scotland criticised the SNP government for failing to set out long-term funding plans for this.
The Scottish Fiscal Commission has also warned there will be a funding gap for devolved social security spending of £1.2 billion by 2030/31.
However Education Secretary Màiri McAllan says the SNP does not see a need to cut benefits like the adult disability payment.
When asked by BBC Radio Scotland Breakfast if she acknowledges the need to cut benefits spending in Scotland, she said: “I don’t accept the need to make arbitrary cuts that leave people without support.
“I believe most of us are two or three things away from relying on social security and I believe it should be there for people.
“For the adult disability payment, you have to prove quite substantially that you need it to live well as a disabled person, and a lot of people are using it to be able to work.
“For many people in today’s economy they are working and having their income supported by social security.”
She did however acknowledge the need for more mental health support for young people, and said it is “fine to debate” a “shifting emphasis” on this.
Her comments have been heavily criticised by opposition parties in Holyrood who say it shows the SNP has “no realistic plan” to get young people off of benefits and into paid work.
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay said: “This glib refusal to accept that the SNP’s obscenely expensive benefits system is out-of-control confirms they remain in a state of dangerous denial.


“Scottish taxpayers and those in genuine need of support know that the system is unfair and unaffordable.”
Angela Ross MSP, Reform UK’s finance spokeswoman, said: “The SNP has run Scotland’s economy for 20 years and Màiri McAllan is still scapegoating Brexit and Westminster for their shortcomings.
“Thousands of young people across Scotland are not in education, employment or training and the SNP has no realistic plan to get them back into meaningful work.
“Cutting the bloated welfare budget is not an ‘arbitrary cut’ - it is the only way to heal a broken economy and break the cycle of welfare dependency.


“To save a lost generation, young people need stronger pathways from the classroom into worthwhile training schemes or long-term, sustainable work.”
Mark Griffin MSP, Scottish Labour’s social justice spokesman, said: “The Scottish Fiscal Commission has been absolutely clear that the fiscal gap for social security spending in Scotland is set to reach £1.2bn by 2030/31 - the Scottish Government needs to be honest about the pending black hole in public finances.
“We need to take steps to support people into work - creating opportunities for young people, addressing issues in accessing healthcare and addressing the skills gap Scotland faces. Not just for our budget, but because it is the right thing to do.”
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.