Andy Burnham defends welfare reforms in punchiest PMQs yet


After a boring first few PMQs, Andy Burnham brought some fight to the Commons chamber.
For the bulk of Andy Burnham’s appearances at Prime Ministers Questions so far, he has been pretty low key.
When facing attacks from across the chamber he has tended to soak up pressure and attempt to appear reasonable, like the adult in the room.
It has really contrasted with Kemi Badenoch, who always has her knives out.
Her sharpness has always threatened to make things exciting, but The PM’s lack of fight tends to sap the energy out of the room.
But today - after a particularly dull display last week - Andy was full of beans.
Mrs Badenoch expectedly focussed on Tuesday’s Milburn Report on youth unemployment.
She directly asked the PM if he would “cut welfare in this parliament”.
Unsatisfied with his answer, she then teased that this was “more proof that the Labour Party is just the welfare party.”
In the past, the PM has ignored these sort of insults. Not this time.
“She reveals time and time again, when she comes to that dispatch box, why she doesn't understand this issue,” he said with vigour.
“Because she only ever stands at that dispatch box asking for cuts.”
His MPs were buoyed by his combative nature and cheered him on. The Tories - probably a bit shocked by this shift - shouted in anger.
Mrs Badenoch was her usual cutting self: “He says I don’t understand. The only person who doesn’t understand is him.”
But the PM went in two footed with a scathing attack about The Conservatives’ time in office: “They slashed youth services when they were in government.
“They cut the education maintenance allowance. They trebled tuition fees.
“They took hope from a generation. We will give it back to them.”
The Labour MPs loved it. There’s nothing better at getting them going than a good Tory-bashing.
Later Mrs Badenoch said in a condescending tone that she was “just going to clear up some confusion, erm, for the Prime Minister,” before explaining to him how businesses create economic growth. Her MPs laughed loudly and then cheered.
This clearly hit a nerve as Mr Burnham hit back: “She can ask all the self-serving questions that she likes, and she can take a patronising tone if she wants to at that dispatch box.
“But this side of the house is leading on the big issues. We will not let a lost generation be the let down generation.”
This passion has not been seen from a Labour leader at the despatch box since they won the 2024 general election.
Mr Burnham has already had a different approach to Sir Keir Starmer by actually addressing the questions he is asked.
His predecessor would waffle on, read his script and blame the Tories for all the problems facing the country.
The new PM seems to be listening to what is said to him.
He is using these sessions as an opportunity to justify his governments actions, rather than something just to get through each week.
Keeping this punchy approach will help him convince the public he cares in a way that Sir Keir could not.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.