With Brexit costing Scottish government £9m a day, SNP must be involved in UK-EU talks – Stephen Gethins

Scotland – now even more pro-EU than it was in 2016 – should have a seat at the table in Brussels, writes SNP minister Stephen Gethins

Scotland voted by a large majority to remain in the EU and even more people now support rejoining, according to a recent poll. Picture: Jeff J Mitchellplaceholder image
Scotland voted by a large majority to remain in the EU and even more people now support rejoining, according to a recent poll. Picture: Jeff J Mitchell | Getty Images

When the leaders of the UK and European Union meet for their overdue second summit this week, the stakes for Scotland will be high. The first summit in 2025 changed the tone of the relationship but it wasn’t enough. Now we need to start repairing the damage caused by Brexit and ensure that people in Scotland have a say in what comes next.

Scotland's interests, including economic prosperity and energy security, are best served by returning to the EU as soon as possible. The Scottish Parliament endorsed that position just last month – by a margin of three to one, even with Labour abstaining. Scotland shares the EU’s values contained in the bloc’s treaties and would be a committed member.

Rejoining the world’s biggest single market would be good for our businesses because it would remove trade barriers; it would be good for our people because they would regain rights that other Europeans take for granted; and it would also be good for households because it would reduce the cost of living.

EU’s doors are wide open for UK

The Scottish government has always argued for a closer, more constructive relationship with our European neighbours, so I am pleased that the Prime Minister has, at long last, acknowledged Brexit has “done more harm than good” and that the leader of Scottish Labour, Michael Marra, last week argued that the UK should return to the EU. A more realistic debate about the UK's future relationship with Europe is now well underway.

I was sitting alongside my colleague David McAllister, chair of the European Parliament’s foreign affairs committee, when he told an audience in Edinburgh recently that Europe’s door was wide open for the return of the UK. The long-serving German politician, whose father was Scottish, was clear that there is a way forward.

We will back every serious attempt to rebuild a deeper partnership, but I urge the UK government to be more ambitious and go beyond its self-imposed red lines on the Single Market, Customs Union and freedom of movement. A deal within Labour’s limits is simply tinkering, and would leave the worst aspects of a hard Brexit still in place.

70% of Scots support rejoining EU

Evidence of Brexit’s damage is stark. Our modelling suggests that Scotland's public revenues were around £3.3 billion lower in 2025 than they would have been had the UK remained in the EU. That is roughly £9 million every day that could have supported public services, communities and businesses.

Scottish voters knew this would be the outcome of cutting the close ties we once enjoyed with our European neighbours. In 2016 they voted decisively to remain, and YouGov polling in June this year found that 75 per cent of people in Scotland think leaving the EU was wrong and that 70 per cent would support rejoining.

While it looks as though the UK government is unfortunately not yet ready to commit to any truly bold steps, the negotiations underway could still deliver some benefits. A sensible agreement covering food and farming standards, carbon markets, access to the EU electricity market, and a youth experience scheme could all help Scottish businesses and young people.

I want the talks at this summit to be a success, but it will all depend on the detail. Take carbon border charges. Since January, Scottish exporters have told us that compliance costs and reporting burdens are putting economic growth and viability at risk. Mutual exemptions must be secured quickly, and I would like to see help for firms in the meantime.

Scotland part of the energy security solution

My government brief covers energy as well, and I firmly believe Scotland can play a leading role in strengthening Europe’s energy security in response to the challenges of an uncertain world. Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 placed energy security top of the European agenda, and Scotland is part of the solution.

We want closer cooperation on electricity – our offshore wind ambitions and the associated jobs depend on it. That would touch on planning, consents and subsidies, which are decisions for Scotland. Changes negotiated between the UK and EU must not be implemented without us.

Many of the other areas under negotiation fall within the powers of the Scottish Parliament, including education, agriculture and the environment. At the first summit, an agreement was reached on our vital fisheries industry without meaningful discussion with Scottish ministers. That must not happen again.

So, as a start, I have asked the UK government for three things. First, let the devolved governments comment on negotiating mandates before they are agreed. Second, share draft texts at meaningful points in the talks. Third, give our officials proper access to the discussions in the areas that affect us. When the UK takes part in shaping EU rules in future, devolved governments must have a clearly defined role in that too.

A European Partnership Bill will follow the summit and we expect it to be a significant piece of legislation. It will also be a significant test for the Prime Minister to prove he is serious about engaging with us. The Bill must not become another case of decisions being made for Scotland, rather than with Scotland.

We will continue to champion Scotland’s interests, seeking the strongest possible partnership with the EU, while working constructively with the UK government whenever it pursues ambitious goals that match our own.

Stephen Gethins is the SNP MSP for Dundee City East and the Scottish government minister for Europe, external affairs and energy

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice