SNP in denial as ‘perfect’ Scotland’s polycrisis just keeps on growing
With high youth unemployment, long NHS waiting lists, rising crime and falling police officer numbers, Scotland needs a government prepared to recognise problems and take bold action to address them


It’s worth remembering that, as part of the UK, we live in the world’s fifth richest country, that the chances of being murdered are small compared to many other countries, and that, at its best, the National Health Service is amazing. However, in each of these areas – economics, crime and health – the warning signs are multiplying at an alarming rate.
Today we report on the findings of the Milburn Report about how to help the alarming number of young people who are not in education, employment or training, or ‘Neet’. One in six young Scots are currently in this situation, according to Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander, a figure that compares poorly to the proportion south of the Border, where it affects less than one in seven.
Neither statistic is anything to crow about but at least Labour is looking to tackle the problem. They commissioned a major piece of research and are now taking action. Whether they are making the right calls is open to argument, but they are trying.
Little to learn?
The response from SNP Education Secretary Mairi McAllan, who claimed Scotland had already carried out many of the recommended reforms, suggested the Scottish government believes it has little to learn. If true, why is our Neet figure so bad and what is the SNP doing about it? If Scotland’s experience shows the Milburn reforms haven’t worked, where is the nationalists’ alternative plan?
Responding to criticisms from the SNP in the Commons, Labour’s Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told one MP that “if she wants to argue that things are perfect in Scotland, she should speak to the area manager of the Bellshill Job Centre, who last Christmas told me that more than 40 per cent of the youth cohort were on the health journey”.
The burgeoning disability benefits bill is a thorny issue that is being grasped by Labour and the Conservatives, who naturally offer different solutions, but largely ignored by the SNP, who have seen it as an opportunity to make political attacks on Westminster.
READ MORE: Milburn Review: Up to 20,000 young Scots could see health benefits scrapped by Westminster
Downward spirals
There are many reasons behind the problem, but one is the scandalously long waiting lists for treatment on the NHS. As we report today, “Scotland is getting sicker” with half the population living with a long-term condition.
With the right treatment and support, many people could be in work, rather than living on benefits. A smaller workforce means lower tax revenues and, therefore, less money to spend on public services like the NHS or support for young people to find a job – situations that both risk becoming downward spirals.
Lots of young people hanging around with nothing to do and no immediate prospects – particularly those who have recently emerged from schools where discipline has all but broken down – represent a group of people ripe for exploitation by criminals, particularly as courts tend to treat young people more leniently.
‘Fundamental decline’ of trust in police
Gangs of masked youths on e-bikes are just one manifestation of this problem. Figures published this week show that police incidents involving e-bikes and e-scooters have nearly doubled in a year.
And again, as we report today, the Scottish Police Federation, which represents rank-and-file officers, is warning of a “policing crisis” defined by “rising recorded crime, falling officer numbers, and a fundamental decline in public trust of the police to deliver on their priorities”. Scottish Conservative justice spokesman Stephen Kerr said Scotland was “sleepwalking into a law-and-order crisis, and the SNP are refusing to wake up”.
We are fortunate to live in a wonderful country like Scotland. But if things continue on their current path, we are going to find ourselves in a very different place.
