How I helped China embrace the genius of Adam Smith – Professor Zhaoyu Yang

Professor Zhaoyu Yang warns true understanding of Adam Smith can only be found on reading both the major works of Scotland’s greatest moral philosopher

The statue of Scottish economist and moral philosopher Adam Smith on the Royal Mile in Edinburgh. Picture: Oli Scarffplaceholder image
The statue of Scottish economist and moral philosopher Adam Smith on the Royal Mile in Edinburgh. Picture: Oli Scarff | AFP via Getty Images

Today, I will board a train in County Durham and travel north across the Scottish border to the University of Edinburgh to attend a symposium marking the 250th anniversary of Adam Smith’s An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776).

For a retired Chinese professor of economics and management, this journey feels like the closing of a circle that began more than half a century ago. I first encountered Smith in 1973 – as a young student in a China still governed by strict central planning – when I stumbled across the scholar Yan Fu’s pioneering 1902 classical Chinese rendering, called Yuan Fu, which means The Origin of Wealth.

In those austere years, when personal profit and market exchange were condemned as bourgeois heresies, Smith’s quiet, common-sense observation of how human beings truck, barter, and cooperate struck me like a shaft of sunlight through heavy cloud.

Market euphoria in China

Thirty years later, in 2002 – the centenary of Yan Fu’s translation and following China’s entry into the World Trade Organisation – several colleagues and I set out to produce a new, complete vernacular Chinese translation of The Wealth of Nations for ordinary 21st-century readers.

Working from Methuen & Co’s reproduction of Smith’s final lifetime edition, I translated book one – the structural bedrock, covering the division of labour, money, value, and distribution – and co-reviewed the entire manuscript, published by Huaxia Publishing House in Beijing in 2005.

When I finished drafting the translator’s introduction in August 2004, China was in the full flush of market euphoria. GDP growth was worshipped, and the "invisible hand" of the free market was hailed as the eternal crown jewel of economics.

Yet looking back at that preface 22 years later – an introduction that, to my surprise, went on to be widely quoted and even copied out by hand by Chinese readers – what stands out most is not its celebration of market efficiency, but its warning against an incomplete reading of Scotland’s greatest moral philosopher.

‘Half an Adam Smith’

"The world," I wrote in August 2004, "knows only half an Adam Smith." To understand him, I argued then, one cannot separate The Wealth of Nations from his earlier, equally monumental masterpiece, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) – the book Smith himself prized more highly and spent his dying months in Edinburgh revising.

In The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Smith begins with innate human sympathy and constructs an ethics of altruism; in The Wealth of Nations, he begins with self-interest to explain the mechanics of economic gain.

To know The Wealth of Nations without The Theory of Moral Sentiments is to know at most half his works – and if that half is misread as an endorsement of unbridled greed, one understands even less than half. Smith was, first and foremost, a compassionate moral philosopher, and second a penetrating economist.

In that 2004 introduction, I likened Smith’s self-interested economics and altruistic ethics to the binary digits “0 and 1” in computer science: neither can generate a functioning world on its own; only together do they form a complete system.

Even more pressing is how a society balances the two. Truth rarely resides at either extreme; the central challenge facing individuals, organisations, and nations is to locate the golden mean between self-interest and altruism.

Crucially, as I wrote 22 years ago, this golden mean is not static. Constrained by material scarcity, humanity’s pendulum swung toward self-interest in the past; yet as productivity advances and human consciousness matures, the golden mean between self-interest and altruism inevitably shifts toward altruism, and the world gradually comes to recognise Smith’s other half.

Power of the people

At the same time, introducing Smith to a rising Chinese market required clarity about the boundaries of power. Centrally planned economies had failed globally because their assumptions about human nature did not match the reality of our historical stage.

In a genuine market economy, I noted in 2004, economic vitality is driven from below by ordinary citizens pursuing their own betterment rather than dictated from above – in short, in a market economy, power resides with the people, not with the government.

What Smith advocated was never the absence of law, but a limited, accountable state focused on three essential duties: protecting society from external violence, upholding justice among citizens, and maintaining public works and universal education.

Two decades on, standing in Britain as the world commemorates 1776 – a year that gave humanity both The Wealth of Nations and the American Declaration of Independence, advancing economic and political freedom in tandem – those reflections have acquired an unforeseen urgency.

In China, having absorbed the lessons of material wealth creation through the "first half" of Smith, public discourse and scholarship over the past decade have turned increasingly toward The Theory of Moral Sentiments, seeking ethical anchors in both Scottish moral philosophy and classical Confucian notions of compassion (ceyin zhi xin).

The court of conscience

Meanwhile, across the globe, our rapid entry into the age of artificial intelligence and algorithmic capitalism has exposed the peril of building machines in the image of ‘half an Adam Smith’.

Today’s commercial algorithms are programmed with single-minded objective functions – maximising clicks, extraction, and speed – while stripping away the human capacity for sympathy and what Smith called the “impartial spectator”, the court of conscience within our breasts.

Without that moral counterbalance, the invisible hand risks degenerating into an unaccountable, algorithmic monopoly.

On Adam Smith’s modest sandstone headstone in Edinburgh’s Canongate Kirkyard, his epitaph names him first as the author of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and only second as the author of The Wealth of Nations. Today, 250 years on, as scholars gather in Edinburgh to honour his legacy, the greatest tribute we can pay to this Scottish son is to restore that original order – and finally recognise the whole Adam Smith.

Before retiring, Zhaoyu Yang was professor of economics and management at Shenyang Jianzhu University, China

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice