Analysts at kennel manufacturer Benchmark Kennels have surveyed dog owners to find their top treats, with everything from chicken to ice cubes proving popular with pups.
Rebarkable dog blogger Ali Smith says these foods can help massively when it comes to the often trying business of obedience training.
She said: “Certain breeds are definitely easier to train, but there is no ‘disobedient’ breed. Just some who are bred to be independent and some who are bred to work closely with you.
“More biddable breeds include German Shepherds, Labrador Retrievers, Toy Poodles, Border Collies - essentially the breeds that are often deemed ‘smart’ breeds, and the more aloof or independent breeds like Huskies, Harriers, Shiba Inu, and a whole host of terriers are usually equally smart, it can just be more difficult to find their wavelength.”
Treats can provide the perfect reward and incentive for pups to follow commands. Creating this positive connection between food and obedience can speed up the training process massively.
"However, some dogs are also more inclined to work for food than others, such as greedy Labradors and Pugs.
"These breeds happily see treats as their reward whereas working dogs such as Spaniels, Shepherds and Collies might find a toy and a good game of tug and war more enticing. The key to the training process is finding what motivates your dog in particular.”
Here’s what the survey found to be the most effective training treats.
Read more

5. KIbble
A pocketful of kibble - the protein-rich processed food made especially for animals - should have your pup hanging on your every command. Photo: Canva/Getty Images

6. Beef liver
Either freeze-dried, baked or boiled, beef liver makes for a particularly nutritious doggy treat. Photo: Canva/Getty Images

7. Ice cubes
Ideal for taining pups in warm conditions - ice cubes give your dog a crunchy treat and cool them down. An additional bonus is that they are a zero calorie snack. Photo: Canva/Getty Images

8. Carrots
Perhaps surprisingly, many dogs can't get enough of the crunchy consistency of slices of raw carrot. It's one of the healthiest treats so you don't have to be too worried about how much they eat. Photo: Canva/Getty Images

